Court Verdicts

Brazil’s SAF Law addresses club labor liabilities

By Dinda Maharani · · 6 min read
Brazil's SAF Law addresses club labor liabilities - saf law
The SAF model cannot be separated from the historical debt burden of Brazilian football.

Brazil’s Law 14.193/21 introduced the Football Limited Company (SAF) model to address the structural crisis in Brazilian football, marked by chronic debt, unprofessional management, limited access to credit, and low legal security for investors.

How the SAF Law Works

The law does more than allow football clubs to transform into limited companies; it structures a specific regime for their formation, governance, financing, and debt restructuring. This brings football closer to the capital markets and modern corporate discipline.

Debt and Labor Liabilities: A Complex Legacy

The SAF model cannot be separated from the historical debt burden of Brazilian football. The law aims to balance asset restructuring, activity preservation, and investment attraction in a low-solvency environment with accumulated past obligations.

Labor liabilities are particularly significant due to the tension between the SAF’s asset segregation and labor law protections. While the law provides rules for pre-SAF debts, debates continue about the limits of this protection in cases of labor succession, economic groups, and execution redirection.

Resolving this issue requires a systematic reading of Articles 2, 9, 10, 12, and 24 of the SAF Law alongside Articles 10, 448, and 448-A of the CLT and constitutional labor protections. The analysis must start with the liability regime outlined in the SAF Law itself.

Centralized Execution Regime

The financial flow outlined in Article 10 of the SAF Law is key. The original club is exclusively and integrally responsible for pre-SAF obligations. However, the new company contributes by allocating 20% of its monthly non-financial income to the original club under the Centralized Execution Regime (RCE), as per a creditor-approved plan.

For example, if the SAF earns R$10 million in a month, R$2 million goes toward settling past debts. This shows that while assets are separated, the new company economically contributes to historical debt settlement through a predefined mechanism.

The RCE is key for organizing this flow and preventing scattered executions. It consolidates executions, linked revenues, and collected amounts before the respective centralizing courts, keeping labor and civil obligations separate under the competent Labor and Civil Courts.

The Supreme Federal Court (STF) upheld the constitutionality of centralized labor executions in ADIn 6.047. It ruled that centralization by Labor Courts is an administrative organization technique within their autonomy, rationalizing execution, reducing asset competition, and promoting equitable creditor treatment without compromising due process or the priority of labor credits.

However, the RCE is not an unconditional moratorium or “shield.” It depends on a viable plan, regular payments, and judicial oversight.

Labor Succession and Legal Uncertainty

The special regime does not eliminate the need to define how it applies when corporate restructuring affects labor credits. The issue goes beyond who pays past debts to include the characterization of succession itself.

Labor law doctrine is divided. The traditional view requires both the transfer of the economic unit and the continuity of service provision to the successor.

In the context of SAFs, this debate is critical because the football department’s separation transfers the core economic activity to the new company. However, treating every separation as automatic succession could undermine the special regime.

Related Post: Court to rule on late defense claims

Labor Succession Dilemma

The key distinction is between authorized restructuring and actual material succession, which involves substantial economic continuity, functional use of the previous structure, or concrete assumption of labor relations.

This uncertainty means the issue cannot be resolved by a literal reading of conflicting provisions. A solution requires harmonizing the SAF Law, CLT, and the Constitution, considering both normative text and the legal model’s purpose and material reality.

From a legal interpretation perspective, the SAF Law’s specificity removes the presumption of succession but does not prevent labor law application when facts indicate material succession, asset confusion, or abusive use of corporate form.

The controversy then extends to execution mechanisms targeting the SAF. Even without recognized succession, discussions persist about economic groups, abuse of legal personality, and subjective expansion of execution.

Supreme Court Theme 1.232 is particularly relevant here. The STF ruled that enforcing a labor judgment generally cannot target a company that did not participate in the trial phase, even in economic group cases. Redirection to a third party is allowed only in succession or abuse of legal personality cases, with proper procedural guarantees.

For SAFs, this precedent imposes stricter filters on liability attempts based solely on corporate proximity, requiring concrete evidence to overcome the separation between the original club and the SAF.

Judicial tension is evident in cases like 0010052-44.2022.5.03.0012, where the 3rd Panel of the 3rd Regional Labor Court upheld joint liability for the club and SAF. It found that the activity was part of the new company’s purpose, the football department’s separation constituted labor succession, and shared interests allowed economic group recognition.

The Superior Labor Court (TST) took a different approach in two cases involving Cruzeiro SAF. In RR 0010281-16.2022.5.03.0105, the contract was still active when the SAF was formed, and the TST upheld the lower court’s liability decision. However, in RR 0010732-59.2022.5.03.0002, where the contract ended before SAF formation, the TST excluded the new company, holding the original club responsible with the SAF’s subsidiary liability limited to legal conditions.

The significant divergence lies in the legal basis. The 3rd Regional Labor Court relied on labor succession, economic group, and functional linkage, while the TST prioritized the SAF Law’s special regime and used contract validity as a liability determinant.

Judicial Tension and New Laws

This judicial variation influenced subsequent legislation. Bill 2.978/23, now Law 15.427/26, amended Article 2 of the SAF Law to explicitly provide for succession in active contracts with athletes and football-related personnel, aligning the law with judicial distinctions.

The project approved by Congress intended to advance further in protecting the SAF’s assets by preventing the automatic formation of an economic group, restricting liability to expressly transferred obligations, and expanding protection against asset constraints. These provisions were vetoed by the President, citing risks of artificial segregation structures between formally separate but materially integrated entities, potentially harming creditors. Veto 28/26 remains pending congressional review.

Bill 3.032/23 is still under consideration, awaiting a rapporteur in the Constitution, Justice, and Citizenship Committee. It seeks to amend Article 9 to broadly establish SAF non-liability for original club obligations, except as legally provided.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.