
Brazil’s nuclear liability regime combines three distinct elements: the operator’s legal liability limit, the federal government’s subsidiary guarantee, and the insurance coverage for the Almirante Álvaro Alberto Nuclear Power Plant (CNAAA). These elements must be analyzed separately.
This distinction is essential. Brazil’s legal limit remains expressed in an extinct monetary unit (ORTN), while the current CNAAA policy shows an aggregate insured base of approximately $2.025 billion. There is, therefore, a significant difference between Brazil’s formal legal regime for nuclear liability and the contractual insurance structure associated with its nuclear power plant.
Brazil’s Nuclear Liability Regime
Brazil’s regime is based on two complementary principles. The first is the objectification of liability imposed by the Constitution and reproduced in the special law. The second is channeling, which concentrates the duty to repair on the operator. Both principles derive from international conventions and condition the contracting of insurance. Their combination explains the acceptance of nuclear risk by the international reinsurance market.
Civil liability for nuclear damage in Brazil is structured primarily in Law No. 6,453 of October 17, 1977. This law addresses civil liability for nuclear damage and criminal liability for acts related to nuclear activities. Brazil’s regime adopts the classic principles of international nuclear law: strict liability, channeling of liability to the operator, limitation of liability, requirement for insurance or financial guarantee, and time limitation on compensation claims.
Brazil’s Nuclear Liability: Strict and Joint Responsibility
The Federal Constitution also plays a role, establishing that civil liability for nuclear damage is independent of fault. Practically, this means victims of nuclear damage need not prove negligence, imprudence, or incompetence by the operator. It suffices to demonstrate the damage, the nuclear accident, and the causal link.
This rule is contained in Article 21, XXIII, “d” of the Constitution. The Superior Court of Justice (STJ) affirmed this in the Goiânia radiological accident case, stating that “strict and joint liability applies to nuclear and radiological accidents, which are equivalent for sanitary-environmental surveillance purposes” (STJ, REsp 1.180.888/GO, 2nd Panel, rel. min. Herman Benjamin, j. 17/6/2010, DJe 28/2/2012).
Law No. 6,453/1977 channels liability to the nuclear facility operator, who is exclusively liable for nuclear damage caused by accidents at the facility or involving its nuclear material. This channeling is a typical feature of international nuclear liability regimes, preventing scattered litigation against suppliers, designers, manufacturers, or carriers, and concentrating liability on a single entity.
The operator’s right to seek recourse against third parties is restricted. Generally, recourse is only admitted when there is an express written contractual provision or when a natural person has intentionally caused the accident. This limitation protects the nuclear supply chain from indeterminate exposure while requiring the operator to maintain adequate financial coverage.
Legal Compensation Limit: 1,500,000 ORTN per Nuclear Accident
Article 9 of Law No. 6,453/1977 sets the liability cap in a monetary unit abolished over three decades ago. The federal government’s guarantee, under Article 14, follows the same limit.
Converting ORTN to current currency involves divergent methods, complicating insurance planning and risk assessment. A legislative review in the Federal Senate aims to address this issue.
Operator Liability Cap and Government Guarantee
Article 9 of Law No. 6,453/1977 limits the operator’s liability for nuclear damage repair to 1,500,000 ORTN per accident. This excludes default interest, attorney’s fees, and court costs. The federal government guarantees compensation up to this limit if the operator’s insurance is insufficient, as per Article 14.
This is Brazil’s regime’s main technical-legal problem. ORTN, a former monetary correction unit, is no longer a contemporary operational reference. While the legal limit exists, its conversion into current currency (reais, dollars, euros, or SDRs) is neither direct nor satisfactory for insurance planning, economic regulation, international comparison, or risk modeling.
This creates a significant asymmetry: Brazil has a structured legal regime with an obsolete statutory ceiling. This raises uncertainty about the limit’s sufficiency in a severe accident, especially compared to modernized international conventions.
ORTN transitioned to OTN in 1986, OTN to BTN in 1989, and BTN was abolished in 1991, each with its conversion factor. Bill No. 5,635/25 proposes replacing the fixed ceiling with a damage-based criterion, updated by an official index, and awaits a rapporteur in the Environment Committee.
Insurance or Financial Guarantee of the Operator
The mandatory financial guarantee derives from three sources. The law requires the operator to maintain it. The regulatory authority sets its nature and value. The insurance contract specifies the plant’s annual coverage. The disconnect between these sources complicates identifying the actual amount available to victims.
Law No. 6,453/1977 mandates that operators maintain insurance or financial guarantees to cover nuclear damage liability. The guarantee’s nature and value are defined within the regulatory framework, considering the facility’s characteristics, purpose, power, location, risks, and operating conditions.
After October 30, 2026, the subsequent contract summary was not yet available in public sources.
Related Post: Roberts expands presidential power over federal agencies
Legal vs. Contractual Insurance Limits
The distinction between the legal limit and the policy’s contractual limit is central to understanding Brazil’s situation.
The insurance limit stems from the policy contracted by Eletronuclear for CNAAA. The 2025 public summary suggests an aggregate insured base of $2.025 billion, covering civil liability, material damage, and fuel transport to UAS.
If the civil liability sublimit exceeds the converted ceiling, the excess does not expand victims’ rights. Conversely, any shortfall falls on the operator and, subsidiarily, the federal government.
The federal government acts as a subsidiary guarantor but not an unlimited one.
Brazil’s regime lacks a broad, permanent, supplementary public nuclear compensation fund seen in modern international regimes. The federal guarantee is tied to the same legal limit as the operator.
After the Goiânia accident, Law No. 9,425/1996 established a special pension for victims outside any ceiling. State liability for inspection omissions, based on Article 37, § 6 of the Constitution, is not subject to the ORTN limit. Bill No. 5,635/25 conditions federal liability on proven inspection omissions and exhaustion of contracted guarantees.
Exclusions, Time Limits, and Compensation Claims
Law No. 6,453/1977 defines exclusions and time limits for claims, determining who receives compensation and when.
Apportionment among creditors is part of this procedural core. Personal injury claims take priority in distributing insufficient resources. Concentrating lawsuits in a single federal court facilitates this apportionment.
Law No. 6,453/1977 excludes liability for damage caused by armed conflict, hostilities, civil war, insurrection, or exceptional natural phenomena. Liability may also be excluded if damage results exclusively from the victim’s fault.
The compatibility of these exclusions with the Constitution is debated, as case law considers “unacceptable the invocation of liability exclusions by companies responsible for environmental damage” (STJ, REsp 1.374.284/MG, 2nd Section, Theme 707, rel. min. Luis Felipe Salomão, j. 27/8/2014, DJe 5/9/2014). The exclusions in Articles 6 and 8 replicate Article IV of the Vienna Convention, offering an argument for their preservation.
Compensation claims generally prescribe after 10 years from the accident date. For accidents involving stolen, lost, or abandoned nuclear material, the period is counted from the accident but cannot exceed 20 years from the theft, loss, or abandonment.
Article 11 concentrates lawsuits for the same accident in the federal court with prior jurisdiction. The ten-year period contrasts with the 1997 Protocol, which extended the period to 30 years for death and personal injury.
Brazil is a party to the 1963 Vienna Convention on Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage, in force since June 26, 1993, by accession deposited on March 26, 1993. However, Brazil is not a party to the 1997 Protocol amending the Vienna Convention, the Convention on Supplementary Compensation for Nuclear Damage (CSC), or the Joint Protocol relating to the Paris and Vienna Conventions.
The 1963 Vienna Convention establishes minimum common principles: exclusive operator liability, strict liability, minimum compensation, insurance obligation, time limitation, equal victim treatment, and exclusive jurisdiction of the incident state’s courts.
The 1997 Protocol sought to modernize this regime, expanding scope, increasing compensation, and strengthening mechanisms for adequate compensation. As Brazil did not adopt this protocol, it remains bound by the 1963 Vienna Convention, complemented by domestic law.
The revised Vienna regime and the Convention on Supplementary Compensation reference 300 million SDRs as the minimum national compensation, approximately $410 million. The revised Paris/Brussels system operates with even higher values, including operator compensation in the hundreds of millions of euros and supplementary mechanisms reaching around 1.5 billion euros. Some mature nuclear jurisdictions adopt unlimited operator liability with specific financial guarantee requirements.