Law Briefs

STJ: Screenshots valid as civil evidence without notarial record

By Tia Ramadhani · · 2 min read
STJ: Screenshots valid as civil evidence without notarial record - screenshots valid evidence
Minister Nancy Andrighi, the rapporteur, noted that Article 369 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows parties to use legally and morally legitimate means to demonstrate facts.

The Third Panel of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) ruled that screen captures from messaging apps may be used as evidence in civil proceedings without notarial records. The panel decided unanimously that the absence of a notarial record does not, by itself, justify rejecting these prints.

The panel annulled the appealed decision and ordered the case sent back to the originating court to reopen the fact-finding phase and verify the conformity of the screenshots.

Legal Basis for Screenshots

Minister Nancy Andrighi, the rapporteur, noted that Article 369 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows parties to use legally and morally legitimate means to demonstrate facts. She stated that a screenshot fits this system because it has a photographic nature: it records, visually and instantaneously, the content displayed on an electronic device.

Therefore, it should follow the discipline of Article 422 of the CPC, which establishes a relative presumption of veracity. However, its probative value remains subject to specific opposition by the opposing party.

If there is an objection regarding the image’s conformity, electronic authentication will be necessary. If not possible, an expert evaluation may be required.

The minister emphasized that Article 384 of the CPC provides for notarial records as an option to document facts, including in digital environments, and not as a mandatory condition to admit screenshots. Thus, a party may seek a notary to register the content, but the lack of this measure does not automatically make the evidence inadmissible.

Differences from Criminal Proceedings

Minister Daniela Teixeira, who joined the opinion, clarified that the civil discussion should not be confused with the requirements of the criminal sphere. She explained that criminal proceedings involve greater rigor due to the possibility of conviction and situations where the device is seized, making it difficult for the defense to access the content.

In the analyzed case, both parties have access to the conversation and can question the image’s authenticity, as happens with other photographs.

By unanimity, the panel granted the appeal to have the conformity of the screenshots verified in the original court. The decision admits this method of evidence, without dispensing the analysis of its authenticity when contested.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.